Heterogeneous global crop yield response to biochar: a meta-regression analysis
with Samuel Abiven, Simon Jeffery & Margaret Torn
Environmental Research Letters (forthcoming) Abstract: Biochar may contribute to climate change mitigation at negative cost by sequestering photosynthetically-fixed carbon in soil while increasing crop yields. The magnitude of biochar's potential in this regard will depend on crop yield benefits, which have not been well-characterized across different soils and biochars. Using data from 84 studies, we employ meta-analytical, missing data, and semiparametric statistical methods to explain heterogeneity in crop yield responses across different soils, biochars, and agricultural management factors, and then estimate potential changes in yield across different soil environments globally. We find that soil cation exchange capacity and organic carbon were strong predictors of yield response, with low cation exchange and low carbon associated with positive response. We also find that yield response increases over time since initial application, compared to non-biochar controls. High reported soil clay content and low soil pH were weaker predictors of higher yield response. No biochar parameters in our dataset -- biochar pH, percentage carbon content, or temperature of pyrolysis -- were significant predictors of yield impacts. Projecting our fitted model onto a global soil database, we find the largest potential increases in areas with highly weathered soils, such as those characterizing much of the humid tropics. Richer soils characterizing much of the world's important agricultural areas appear to be less likely to benefit from biochar.
Paper (and supporting information) Data and R code Unpublished studies used in the analysis
Works in progress:
"The economics of biochar in smallholder agriculture: evidence from Vietnam and Kenya" (joint with Alex de Pinto (IFPRI) and Abigail Clare (U Edinburgh))
"Greenhouse gas balance of biochar production and decomposition across three representative technologies"